Retention marketing audit

A retention audit shows how many first-time buyers come back, when they drop off and which flows bring them back. Shero reviews your Klaviyo flows, segments, send cadence, loyalty program and win-back timing against repeat purchase rate and cohort data, then gives you a ranked list of fixes.

Vienna Beef logo
Dillanos Coffee Roasters logo
Invisible Bead Extensions (IBE) logo
Archer Roose logo
Shopify Platinum Partner

16+

Years in business

500+

Projects Delivered

65+

Team Members

98%

Client Retention

18%

Higher email ROAS for Archer Roose

After our Shopify 2.0 redesign for Archer Roose, return on ad spend from their email marketing went up 18%.

Altobucks

Loyalty program kept through the migration

Alto Music's Altobucks loyalty program was preserved when they moved to Shopify. Their repeat customers kept the program they already knew.

Flow audit

Long Island Watch's Klaviyo flows checked before launch

Before Long Island Watch moved to Shopify, we audited every Klaviyo flow, found which ones broke on the new store and recreated the ones it needed on Shopify triggers, with back-in-stock subscribers imported at go-live.

Recharge + Klaviyo

Subscriber notices made for Coffee Bean Direct

We developed a custom Shopify app that connects Recharge and Klaviyo, matches affected subscribers by variant and price, and sends each one a personalized price change notice, with a send log you can export. Email and SMS management is there if you want us to make the changes.

"This has been the most impressive vendor partnership I have experienced. Every meeting felt purposeful, every milestone was clear, and the process was incredibly well-supported from start to finish."

Kendra Borkholder, Operations Support, GEN-Y Hitch

What a retention marketing audit covers

Shero's retention audit reviews your email and SMS flows, list segmentation, send cadence, loyalty program mechanics, win-back strategy, and revenue attribution across retention channels. The output is a gap analysis and prioritized action plan covering quick wins and structural changes, with monthly deliverables mapped to revenue targets.

  • Email flow audit (welcome, cart, post-purchase)
  • SMS program review
  • List segmentation and health
  • Loyalty program mechanics
  • Win-back and lapsed customer strategy
  • Revenue attribution by channel

Retention marketing audit: your options compared

How Shero compares with Klaviyo's own benchmarks, a retention freelancer and your in-house email marketer.

Compared on Shero retention auditKlaviyo's own benchmarksA retention freelancerYour in-house email marketer
Flows earning little next to campaigns We audit every flow and compare it with your campaigns, so you see which flows earn little and why.Shows how flows compare with peers, without the causeRebuilds one or two flows in scopeToo close to the setup to see the gaps
Revenue per recipient We report revenue per recipient for every flow and campaign next to opens and clicks.Shows your industry median, handy for a quick checkRarely measures per recipientTracks opens more than dollars
Second orders from first-time buyers We map post-purchase flows and timing aimed at the second orderNo repeat rate by flowAdds a post-purchase flow from a templateKnows repeat buyers, lacks time to segment them
Bounces and spam on a messy list We segment by engagement and check bounce and spam rates before changing how often you send.Flags deliverability against peersPauses sends when complaints spikeFinds out when the platform sends a warning
How you pay An audit of your store or accounts, then a proposal. Work on a monthly retainer.Included in KlaviyoFlat fee per auditSalary, already on payroll
Shero retention audit
Flows earning little next to campaigns We audit every flow and compare it with your campaigns, so you see which flows earn little and why.
Revenue per recipient We report revenue per recipient for every flow and campaign next to opens and clicks.
Second orders from first-time buyers We map post-purchase flows and timing aimed at the second order
Bounces and spam on a messy list We segment by engagement and check bounce and spam rates before changing how often you send.
How you pay An audit of your store or accounts, then a proposal. Work on a monthly retainer.

Compared with

Klaviyo's own benchmarks

Flows earning little next to campaigns Shows how flows compare with peers, without the cause
Revenue per recipient Shows your industry median, handy for a quick check
Second orders from first-time buyers No repeat rate by flow
Bounces and spam on a messy list Flags deliverability against peers
How you pay Included in Klaviyo

A retention freelancer

Flows earning little next to campaigns Rebuilds one or two flows in scope
Revenue per recipient Rarely measures per recipient
Second orders from first-time buyers Adds a post-purchase flow from a template
Bounces and spam on a messy list Pauses sends when complaints spike
How you pay Flat fee per audit

Your in-house email marketer

Flows earning little next to campaigns Too close to the setup to see the gaps
Revenue per recipient Tracks opens more than dollars
Second orders from first-time buyers Knows repeat buyers, lacks time to segment them
Bounces and spam on a messy list Finds out when the platform sends a warning
How you pay Salary, already on payroll

Why eCommerce brands work with Shero on retention

Retention programs that were set up and never reviewed accumulate structural problems: decaying lists, mis-sequenced flows, and underperforming segments that suppress revenue month after month.

01

Audit first, then fix

Shero starts every retention engagement with an audit of what is already in place. Adding new flows on top of a broken foundation does not fix the problem. Alto Music's Alto Bucks loyalty program was kept through the migration and rebuilt on Shopify with Rise.ai.

02

Klaviyo configured for your actual customer segments

Many Klaviyo accounts attribute revenue incorrectly. Shero audits attribution settings before evaluating flow performance. Analytics accuracy is verified alongside Klaviyo configuration so revenue attribution is consistent across email and site reporting.

03

Abandoned cart recovery that goes beyond the default flow

Abandoned cart flows are the highest-value automation for most Shopify brands. Shero assesses abandoned cart setup alongside checkout conversion data; the two are linked because the cart abandonment rate determines how much the recovery flow can recover.

04

Win-back strategy for lapsed customers who are worth recovering

Not all lapsed customers are worth a win-back campaign. Shero segments the lapsed list by historical value and purchase recency before designing the win-back sequence, so the recovery spend targets the accounts most likely to return and least likely to damage deliverability.

05

SMS set up as a retention channel

SMS programmes that send the same message to the full list degrade deliverability over time. Shero audits opt-in copy, send frequency, segmentation, and conversion rates, then recommends changes that improve revenue per message without increasing opt-out rates.

06

Revenue attribution that shows retention's actual contribution

Many brands underestimate retention revenue because their attribution model attributes repeat purchases to the last paid channel click. Shero configures attribution so email and SMS revenue is correctly credited, giving leadership an accurate view of retention ROI versus acquisition spend.

Email marketing results

Numbers from client stores we have worked with.

View all case studies

Specialty coffee

22.6% to 64.8%email campaign open rate, Feb to Jun 2026
Email + SMSprogram managed by our team
Dillanos Coffee RoastersShopify

Wine

+18%email marketing ROAS
Rechargecustom subscription widget built for the new theme
Archer RooseShopify
Read the case study

Our Work

View All
Specialty Coffee

Valentine Coffee Co.

With an existing Shopify build that no longer reflected its premium positioning, the Milwaukee specialty coffee roaster, serving both D2C customers and a growing B2B wholesale base, partnered with Shero to deliver a full design and functionality refresh in 8 to 10 weeks ahead of the holiday season. The project included a refined dark-mode aesthetic, native RoasterTools integration, and a B2B wholesale flow integrated into the storefront.

Valentine Coffee Co.
Canned Wine

Archer Roose

Archer Roose is a wine company known for producing high-quality, sustainably sourced wines in eco-friendly formats like cans and kegs. Their commitment to small, organic, and biodynamic vineyards has helped them stand out in a competitive market. They saw an increase of +18% in email marketing ROAS and 35% improvement in mobile browsing session duration.

Archer Roose
Premium Chocolates

Sarris Candies

Sarris Candies is a family-owned Pennsylvania chocolate maker known for personalized chocolate bars, custom cakes, and gift assortments. Having outgrown its custom .NET platform, the brand moved to Shopify Plus with Shero for a mobile-first storefront, custom personalization, and ordering options for gift buyers and bulk purchasers. With every high-traffic page manually redirected, organic search recovered and grew past pre-migration levels, with Core Web Vitals in the green from launch.

Sarris Candies
Golf Putters and Gear

Swag Golf

Swag Golf is known for its limited-edition, bold golf gear and lifestyle products with a devoted following. Looking to align their online store with their unapologetic brand identity, the brand partnered with Shero to overhaul their Shopify theme, develop a dedicated evergreen product strategy, and drive stronger conversions. The redesign led to a +28% increase in mobile conversion rate and tripled load speed.

Swag Golf

Tracking set up before we spend

Bad tracking wastes ad budget, so we check GA4, pixels and conversion events before the first campaign goes live.

  • GA4 and pixels

    Meta, Google and TikTok events checked against real orders.

  • Feeds

    Product feeds cleaned for Google Shopping and Meta catalogs.

  • Attribution

    One view of what each channel brings in.

  • Reporting

    Monthly report tied to revenue and margin.

A retention audit takes about two weeks. Send us your repeat purchase rate.

Request a retention audit

Process

How a retention marketing audit works

We check your email, SMS and loyalty programs against your order data to find where repeat revenue is leaking.

  1. 01

    Access and baseline

    We connect Klaviyo, your loyalty app and Shopify and record repeat rate, time to second order and flow revenue.

  2. 02

    Program audit

    We review every flow, segment, SMS consent path and loyalty rule for gaps and outdated offers.

  3. 03

    Cohort check

    We study customer cohorts by first product and channel to see which groups come back and which never do.

  4. 04

    Fix plan

    You get a ranked list of fixes with the expected revenue impact of each one.

  5. 05

    Implementation

    We rebuild the flows and segments in the plan and review repeat revenue with you monthly.

Frequently asked questions.

Can't find what you're looking for? Reach out to our team.

What our clients say.

We design experiences that make a difference. See what our clients have to say about working with us.

Alto Music

"As a long-time client, we at Alto Music have always appreciated their technical expertise, but their recent migration of our site from Magento 2 to Shopify was exceptional. Shero preserved the essence of our beloved loyalty and rewards program, seamlessly integrating it into Shopify’s more efficient framework. The transition not only retained our unique features but also significantly simplified site management and reduced costs. We’re thrilled with the results and highly recommend Shero for any e-commerce needs."

Bobby Montemurro

VP Sales & Marketing / Alto Music

Painful Pleasures

"Our journey from Magento to Shopify was riddled with complexities and challenges. With a vast catalog and intricate B2B logic, we needed expertise that could navigate through these intricacies. Shero Commerce was our beacon. They not only provided innovative solutions but also utilized their vast Magento knowledge to bridge gaps in Shopify’s native features. Now, our platform is seamless, our costs are reduced, and the headaches are a thing of the past. A heartfelt thank you to the Shero team!"

Patrick Rice

CEO / Painful Pleasures

Swag Golf

"We partnered with Shero for the SWAG site development. The dev was highly nuanced, specialized and complex. The Shero team went above and beyond. They were collaborative, organized and professional, consistently setting expectations clearly and usually exceeding them."

Matt Kaminsky

Co-founder & Managing Director / Swag Golf

Benchmade Knife Co.

"I wanted to take a moment to thank you all for a very successful launch! I know there was a lot of great work put in by everyone to make this happen. Our accounting and sales teams are thrilled to have this functionality working, and that means our customers are also taking full advantage of these enhancements.
We appreciate the partnership in the development and testing, and are looking forward to more enhancements in the future."

Bren Rafaelly

Head of Digital Transformation / Benchmade Knife Co.

And you?

Let's build something great together.

Ready to scale your eCommerce business? Tell us about your project and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Locations
New York • London • Helsinki • Tirana