Big Cartel to Shopify Migration Services

Outgrown Big Cartel and ready to move your shop to Shopify? We export your products, variants, customers and order history from Big Cartel and map them into Shopify, recreate your design on a Shopify theme, move your domain over and redirect old Big Cartel URLs to their new Shopify pages.

The Endless Skein logo
Taking Cara Babies logo
Just Candy logo
Journey Art Stuff (formerly Cheap Joe's) logo
Shopify Platinum Partner

16+

Years in business

500+

Projects Delivered

65+

Team Members

98%

Client Retention

No cap

Products allowed on Shopify plans

Big Cartel limits how many products each plan allows. Shopify has no product cap on any plan, so a growing catalog does not push you onto a higher tier. For brands that have outgrown Big Cartel's product limits or need features beyond its standard toolset, the migration is straightforward.

CSV export

What Big Cartel lets you export

Big Cartel's CSV export covers products, customers, and orders. Shero maps the URL structure and prepares the redirect map before the new store launches.

+32%

Google clicks at Camera Source after the move

Camera Source moved from Magento to Shopify and Google clicks rose 32% in the 12 weeks after launch. We prepare the same kind of redirect map for Big Cartel stores so old product links keep their Google traffic.

Theme

New Shopify theme with the move

Big Cartel themes do not transfer to Shopify, so we set up the new store on an Online Store 2.0 theme your team can edit without code. We add the features Big Cartel could not support, like reviews, bundles and email signup.

Working with Shero Commerce on our Shopify project was an absolute pleasure. Their team demonstrated exceptional expertise and professionalism. They transformed our vision into a stunning and user-friendly online store.

Vienna Beef, Reid Schwartz, eCommerce Manager

What transfers in a Big Cartel migration

Big Cartel is not a standalone storefront in the way Shopify is, so most brands need a Shopify theme designed alongside the data migration. Here's what transfer and what the setup involves:

  • Big Cartel product catalog export and Shopify import
  • Customer record and order history transfer
  • URL redirect map from Big Cartel to Shopify URL structure
  • SEO metadata, page titles, and descriptions migrated
  • Shopify store design for brands moving to a standalone storefront
  • App stack setup: reviews, email, analytics to replace Big Cartel's native tools

Big Cartel to Shopify migration: your options compared

How Shero compares with staying on Big Cartel, a migration app like Cart2Cart or LitExtension, and a freelancer.

Compared on Big Cartel to Shopify migration agencyStay on Big CartelMigration app like Cart2Cart or LitExtensionFreelancer
Products, photos and options Every product, photo and option checked against Big Cartel before launchNothing movesMoves products, images, customers and orders, fast and cheapUsually a CSV export and import
Customer list and email signups Customers imported with each person's email consent kept as recordedStays in Big CartelMoves customer recordsDepends on how they map the file
Your time during the move We handle the move, you approve the new storeNone neededYou do the import and set up the storeLess of your time, depending on scope
Launch day Test orders placed on the new store before the domain movesNo launch to planYou test and launch itTheir checklist, their schedule
How you pay Paid discovery, then an accurate estimate.A monthly Big Cartel planA fee based on the number of recordsA flat quote or hourly
Big Cartel to Shopify migration agency
Products, photos and options Every product, photo and option checked against Big Cartel before launch
Customer list and email signups Customers imported with each person's email consent kept as recorded
Your time during the move We handle the move, you approve the new store
Launch day Test orders placed on the new store before the domain moves
How you pay Paid discovery, then an accurate estimate.

Compared with

Stay on Big Cartel

Products, photos and options Nothing moves
Customer list and email signups Stays in Big Cartel
Your time during the move None needed
Launch day No launch to plan
How you pay A monthly Big Cartel plan

Migration app like Cart2Cart or LitExtension

Products, photos and options Moves products, images, customers and orders, fast and cheap
Customer list and email signups Moves customer records
Your time during the move You do the import and set up the store
Launch day You test and launch it
How you pay A fee based on the number of records

Freelancer

Products, photos and options Usually a CSV export and import
Customer list and email signups Depends on how they map the file
Your time during the move Less of your time, depending on scope
Launch day Their checklist, their schedule
How you pay A flat quote or hourly

Why brands choose Shero for Big Cartel migration

The data transfer is simple. The redirect map and store design are where the migration determines whether the new Shopify store performs from day one or requires fixing after launch. Shero handles both before go-live.

01

URL redirects prepared before launch to protect search rankings

Big Cartel and Shopify use different URL structures for products and pages. Every product page needs a 301 redirect from its Big Cartel URL to the Shopify destination before the new store launches. Shero prepares the redirect map, configures it in Shopify, and verifies it in Google Search Console post-launch.

02

Shopify store designed as a full storefront for selling

Big Cartel's look is minimal by design. It suits artists selling a small number of works. Shopify is a full eCommerce storefront. Brands leaving Big Cartel usually need a Shopify theme that reflects their brand and supports the features they are moving for. Shero scopes the design alongside the migration so both complete together.

03

Customer password reset prepared at go-live

Customer passwords cannot transfer between platforms. Shero prepares the reset email and triggers it at launch so customers can log in immediately without contacting support.

04

App stack configured to cover what Big Cartel could not

Big Cartel has no native product reviews, limited analytics, no abandoned cart recovery on lower plans, and no upsell or cross-sell features. After migration, Shero configures the Shopify app stack to cover these gaps, using the integrations work Shero does for Shopify brands.

05

SEO set up correctly on Shopify from the start

Big Cartel's SEO tools are minimal. Moving to Shopify gives full control over metadata, 301 redirects, canonical tags, and structured data. Shero transfers existing metadata, sets up the redirect structure, and monitors search rankings post-launch. This is part of the SEO work Shero does for every platform migration.

06

Product catalog reviewed and cleaned before import

Big Cartel CSV exports sometimes contain fields that need reformatting before importing to Shopify. Shero reviews and prepares the catalog before the import starts so the Shopify store launches with complete, correctly structured product data.

Migration results

Numbers from client stores we have worked with.

View all case studies

Backup camera systems

+32%Google clicks in the 12 weeks after the move from Magento
+65%Google impressions, same 12 weeks vs the 12 before
Camera SourceShopify
Read the case study

Hair extensions

+14.3%conversion rate from two A/B tests
3 to 1platforms merged into one Shopify site
Invisible Bead ExtensionsShopify

Digital products

Ordergroovedigital memberships with free trials and plan changes, connected through custom middleware
Stripesubscriptions and saved cards moved off Stripe at go-live
Shift WorshipShopify

Our Work

View All
Drums and Percussion

Memphis Drum Shop

Memphis Drum Shop sells drums, cymbals, and percussion instruments. To cut costs and modernize their platform, they moved from Magento to Shopify with Shero, with a CounterPoint ERP integration through iPaaS and 3 custom browsing features. Average session duration rose 22% after launch.

Memphis Drum Shop
Lacrosse and Hockey Gear

STX

Looking to scale alongside growing global markets and competitor consolidation, the premium American manufacturer of lacrosse, field hockey, and ice hockey equipment, partnered with Shero to migrate from Adobe Commerce (Magento) to Shopify, delivering a unified D2C and B2B experience, custom ERP integration, and a refined storefront that reflects the engineering quality of their products.

STX
Premium Knives

Benchmade

For more than three decades, Benchmade has been known for producing high-quality knives for everyday carry, hunting, rescue, and outdoor use. Launched on Magento Commerce Cloud in 2018, the brand partnered with Shero to expand online amid rising outdoor consumer demand. Since then, they have seen: +100% revenue growth, +68% transaction growth after relaunch, and a +20% increase in average order value.

Benchmade
Premium Chocolates

Sarris Candies

Sarris Candies is a family-owned Pennsylvania chocolate maker known for personalized chocolate bars, custom cakes, and gift assortments. Having outgrown its custom .NET platform, the brand moved to Shopify Plus with Shero for a mobile-first storefront, custom personalization, and ordering options for gift buyers and bulk purchasers. With every high-traffic page manually redirected, organic search recovered and grew past pre-migration levels, with Core Web Vitals in the green from launch.

Sarris Candies

Your rankings move with you

Migrations usually lose traffic in the redirects and the data. We plan both before a single product moves.

  • Redirect map

    Every old URL mapped to its new Shopify URL and tested before launch.

  • Data that matches

    Products, customers, orders and reviews moved and checked against the source.

  • Apps replaced

    Each plugin or extension matched to a Shopify app or custom code before the build starts.

  • Launch day watch

    Search Console, analytics and checkout monitored through launch week.

Moving from Big Cartel to Shopify? Let's talk.

Book a Discovery Call

Process

How a Big Cartel to Shopify migration works

Big Cartel shops are usually small and simple, so the move focuses on products, options and the links fans already use.

  1. 01

    Discovery and audit

    We list your products, options, categories and pages, and the features you want next on Shopify, and agree scope and acceptance criteria.

  2. 02

    Products

    Big Cartel options become Shopify variants with their own stock, and images and descriptions come across with them.

  3. 03

    Apps

    We add the apps your shop needs, such as email signup and product reviews, and connect them to your products.

  4. 04

    Redirects

    Each Big Cartel product and category link gets a Shopify destination so links in your bio and old posts still work.

  5. 05

    Testing and launch

    Customers and order history are imported, and checkout is tested with live payments and shipping rates. You sign off, then we launch.

Frequently asked questions.

Can't find what you're looking for? Reach out to our team.

What our clients say.

We design experiences that make a difference. See what our clients have to say about working with us.

Swag Golf

"We partnered with Shero for the SWAG site development. The dev was highly nuanced, specialized and complex. The Shero team went above and beyond. They were collaborative, organized and professional, consistently setting expectations clearly and usually exceeding them."

Matt Kaminsky

Co-founder & Managing Director / Swag Golf

Vienna Beef

"Our experience with Shero Commerce has been exceptional. Their expertise in migrating our website to BigCommerce resulted in a seamless transition, and we’ve seen a significant improvement in our checkout process and overall user experience. Their web design skills have truly elevated our online presence, and we couldn’t be happier with the results."

Reid Schwartz

eCommerce Manager / Vienna Beef

Invisible Bead Extensions®

"Working with Shero Commerce on our migration from WordPress to Shopify was honestly such a pleasant experience. We’d been on WordPress for five years with tons of content and very specific styling, and moving all of it into one cohesive Shopify site was no small feat, this was a genuinely complex, highly technical migration. But they pulled it off on deadline with zero errors and zero issues. Their team showed up with everything we needed: a project manager, multiple developers, marketing leads, email specialists, and CRO experts, all coordinated through dedicated meetings and a real task management system. They also designed several high impact conversion pages so our digital presence didn’t just function better, it looked beautiful too. Since migrating, we’ve seen an increase in revenue thanks to having one simplified, cohesive platform. I’m so grateful for how seamlessly they executed this, and I’d recommend Shero Commerce to anyone facing a migration like ours."

Jasmine Hadjis

CEO, IBE / Invisible Bead Extensions®

Camera Source

"Shero did a great job migrating our site from Magento to Shopify. Switching to Shopify went very smooth and I believe it is because of the Shero team. They actually care. I have appreciated the help in answering my questions and guiding us through everything."

Tricia Christianson

Sales and Marketing - Camera Source / Camera Source

And you?

Let's build something great together.

Ready to scale your eCommerce business? Tell us about your project and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Locations
New York • London • Helsinki • Tirana