Shopify Payment Gateway Consulting

Choosing between Shopify Payments, PayPal, Adyen or Authorize.net, or adding Klarna and Afterpay at checkout? Shero compares gateways on your actual fees, countries, currencies, subscriptions and B2B terms, then sets them up in Shopify checkout with Shop Pay, wallets and fraud rules.

GEN-Y Hitch logo
Long Island Watch logo
LaSara logo
Simucube logo
Shopify Platinum Partner

16+

Years in business

500+

Projects Delivered

65+

Team Members

98%

Client Retention

Wallets

Alto Music's wallets and financing in Shopify checkout

We set up Shop Pay, Shop Pay Installments, Affirm, Apple Pay and Google Pay in Alto Music's Shopify checkout, and we handled the front end for its Klarna, Synchrony and Progressive Leasing financing.

200+

Countries covered by PayPal as a fallback gateway

PayPal operates in over 200 countries and serves as a reliable fallback for markets where Shopify Payments is unavailable. Shero configures PayPal and other global gateways as part of international payment strategy.

Stripe

Stored customer cards moved from Stripe to Shopify for Shift Worship

At Shift Worship's go-live we migrated customers' stored cards from Stripe to Shopify. We plan card moves like this before any gateway change.

iDEAL

Local payment methods by market

Shoppers in many countries expect a local payment method, like iDEAL in the Netherlands or Bancontact in Belgium. We turn these on market by market in Shopify Payments or through another gateway, and check that each one shows at checkout.

"This has been the most impressive vendor partnership I have experienced. Every meeting felt purposeful, every milestone was clear, and the process was incredibly well-supported from start to finish."

Kendra Borkholder, Operations Support, GEN-Y Hitch

Your checkout is losing sales you cannot see

Customers who reach checkout often leave without buying. Many merchants assume the problem is price or intent. In many cases it is simpler: a payment method the customer expected to see is missing, a cross-border transaction failed silently, or the gateway is applying fees that make certain markets unprofitable to serve. These problems do not show up as errors.

  • Shopify Payments Configuration
  • Third-Party Gateway Integration
  • International Payment Setup
  • Cross-Border Fee Analysis
  • B2B Payment Workflows
  • Shopify Markets Configuration
  • Gateway Performance Audit
  • Ongoing Optimization

Shopify payment gateway setup: your options compared

How Shero compares with setting it up yourself, your payment provider's team and a freelancer.

Compared on Shopify payment gateway consultantsSet it up yourselfYour payment provider's teamA freelancer
Fees on every order today Your current gateway fees lined up against Shopify Payments before any changeYou compare rate cards on your ownQuotes its own rates, no side by sideDepends on their payments background
Payouts matching your books Payout reports checked against your accounting app before launchGaps tend to show up at month endExplains its own payout reportUsually outside the scope
Test orders before go-live Test orders on every payment method before go-live. At Alto Music we set up Shop Pay, Affirm, Apple Pay and Google Pay.Shopify chat help 24/7, but Shopify points third-party setup to a PartnerTests its own connection onlyA few test orders, if any
Fraud settings after the switch Fraud filters and 3D Secure settings reviewed for the new gatewayDefaults stay on unless you change themOffers its own risk toolsFraud setup is seldom in a gateway gig
How you pay Paid discovery, then an accurate estimate.Your time, plus gateway feesTransaction fees set in your contractHourly
Shopify payment gateway consultants
Fees on every order today Your current gateway fees lined up against Shopify Payments before any change
Payouts matching your books Payout reports checked against your accounting app before launch
Test orders before go-live Test orders on every payment method before go-live. At Alto Music we set up Shop Pay, Affirm, Apple Pay and Google Pay.
Fraud settings after the switch Fraud filters and 3D Secure settings reviewed for the new gateway
How you pay Paid discovery, then an accurate estimate.

Compared with

Set it up yourself

Fees on every order today You compare rate cards on your own
Payouts matching your books Gaps tend to show up at month end
Test orders before go-live Shopify chat help 24/7, but Shopify points third-party setup to a Partner
Fraud settings after the switch Defaults stay on unless you change them
How you pay Your time, plus gateway fees

Your payment provider's team

Fees on every order today Quotes its own rates, no side by side
Payouts matching your books Explains its own payout report
Test orders before go-live Tests its own connection only
Fraud settings after the switch Offers its own risk tools
How you pay Transaction fees set in your contract

A freelancer

Fees on every order today Depends on their payments background
Payouts matching your books Usually outside the scope
Test orders before go-live A few test orders, if any
Fraud settings after the switch Fraud setup is seldom in a gateway gig
How you pay Hourly

Why brands configure payment gateways with Shero

Getting payment gateways right requires understanding your markets, your customers, and your fee structure. This is how Shero approaches it.

01

Payment setup connected to full checkout optimization

Payment gateway configuration and checkout optimisation are part of the same engagement at Shero. Custom checkout optimisation is available for brands that want dedicated conversion testing alongside payment configuration.

02

Every integration tested before go-live

Gateway integrations can introduce checkout errors if not validated correctly. We test every payment method across regions, devices, and order types before going live. No gateway goes active on your store without passing a full checkout test cycle.

03

B2B payment workflows on Shopify Plus

B2B buyers require payment terms, ACH, and PO capture alongside standard card payments. B2B payment terms configuration is a separate engagement for brands that need net terms, partial payments, and deposit workflows.

04

Fee reduction as part of the setup

Cross-border conversion fees, third-party gateway transaction fees, and redundant payment apps all add to your cost of processing. We identify where you are overpaying and configure your gateway stack to reduce fees without reducing coverage.

05

International coverage mapped to your markets

Shopify Payments is available in a limited set of countries. If you sell beyond those markets, or if your customers in supported countries prefer local payment methods, we identify the specific gaps and configure the right third-party gateways for each region.

06

Gateway audit before any recommendations

We review your current gateway setup, transaction failure rates, abandonment data by region, and fee structure before suggesting any changes. Many stores have fixable problems that do not require switching their primary gateway.

App setup results

Numbers from client stores we have worked with.

View all case studies

Musical instruments

40%lower maintenance and operating costs after the move from Magento 2
Altobucksopen loyalty balances moved to Shopify on launch day
Alto MusicShopify
Read the case study

Specialty coffee

+35.8%active subscriptions, Q3 vs Q2 2026
+77.1%new subscriptions, same period
Dillanos Coffee RoastersShopify

Entertainment

Custom appcredit based checkout rebuilt in a custom Shopify app
+40%faster page loads than legacy Magento
Regal CinemasShopify
Read the case study

Our Work

View All
Musical Instruments

Alto Music

Alto Music, a longtime music retailer with loyal customers, collaborated with Shero to switch from Magento 2 to Shopify. They successfully maintained their popular Altobucks loyalty program while moving to a more user-friendly and cost-efficient platform. The transition ensured all loyalty benefits remained intact, and they achieved a 40% reduction in ongoing maintenance expenses.

Alto Music
Movie Theaters

Regal Cinemas

One of the largest cinema chains in the US, Regal Cinemas, partnered with Shero to migrate from Magento to Shopify, building a 100%Credit-based checkout logic replicated in a custom Shopify app, loyalty reward redemption, Vista Cloud integration, and automated corporate gifting workflows across two distinct eCommerce platforms. As a result, they achieved over 40% faster page load time.

Regal Cinemas
Lacrosse and Hockey Gear

STX

Looking to scale alongside growing global markets and competitor consolidation, the premium American manufacturer of lacrosse, field hockey, and ice hockey equipment, partnered with Shero to migrate from Adobe Commerce (Magento) to Shopify, delivering a unified D2C and B2B experience, custom ERP integration, and a refined storefront that reflects the engineering quality of their products.

STX
Tattoo and Piercing Supplies

Painful Pleasures

Painful Pleasures is a long-standing supplier of body jewelry and tattoo supplies with a catalog of 40,000+ products. The brand partnered with Shero to complete a stalled Magento to Shopify migration and deliver the complex custom features their business depends on. They reduced ongoing maintenance costs and eliminated urgent site issues that had previously caused headaches by 40%.

Painful Pleasures

Set up right the first time

App problems usually come from a rushed install: missing data, theme conflicts and scripts that slow the store. We set it up, connect the data and check the speed.

  • Data connected

    Customer, order and product data synced both ways with Shopify.

  • Theme ready

    Widgets and blocks placed in your theme without breaking the layout.

  • Speed checked

    Scripts reviewed so the app does not drag down Core Web Vitals.

  • Hand off

    Your team trained on the settings that matter.

Not sure your payment setup fits your markets?

Let's look at yours

Get a Gateway Audit

Process

How a payment gateway project works

We look at where payments fail today, fix the gaps per market and test every method before it goes live.

  1. 01

    Discovery and gateway audit

    In recorded workshops we review failed transactions, checkout drop-off by country and the fees you pay on each payment method. You get the scope and acceptance criteria.

  2. 02

    Market map

    We list the local payment methods buyers expect in each market and check what Shopify Payments already covers.

  3. 03

    Configure

    Additional gateways, wallets and local methods get set up and ordered at checkout for each region.

  4. 04

    Testing and UAT

    Every payment method is tested with real transactions across regions, devices, currencies and refunds. Your team tests too and signs off.

  5. 05

    Launch

    New methods go live with the old setup ready to restore, and we watch approval rates and fees after launch.

Frequently asked questions.

Can't find what you're looking for? Reach out to our team.

What our clients say.

We design experiences that make a difference. See what our clients have to say about working with us.

Benchmade Knife Co.

"I wanted to take a moment to thank you all for a very successful launch! I know there was a lot of great work put in by everyone to make this happen. Our accounting and sales teams are thrilled to have this functionality working, and that means our customers are also taking full advantage of these enhancements.
We appreciate the partnership in the development and testing, and are looking forward to more enhancements in the future."

Bren Rafaelly

Head of Digital Transformation / Benchmade Knife Co.

STX

"Since partnering with Shero Commerce, our eCommerce revenue has grown by 200%. Their 24/7 support and innovative solutions have been game-changers for our business."

James McKenna

Senior Commerce & CX Manager / STX

Memphis Drum Shop

"Working with the Shero team was professional, efficient, and inspiring. The Shero development team was extremely competent and provided solid solutions for our needs, as well as addressing any bugs or issues that arose during the process. Working with Shero exclusively through video technology was a new concept for our team that forced us to embrace modern methods of communication that will likely benefit our future relationships and business endeavors."

Shaun Carman

eCommerce Manager / Memphis Drum Shop

Swag Golf

"We partnered with Shero for the SWAG site development. The dev was highly nuanced, specialized and complex. The Shero team went above and beyond. They were collaborative, organized and professional, consistently setting expectations clearly and usually exceeding them."

Matt Kaminsky

Co-founder & Managing Director / Swag Golf

And you?

Let's build something great together.

Ready to scale your eCommerce business? Tell us about your project and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Locations
New York • London • Helsinki • Tirana