Square Online to Shopify Migration Services

Moving your store from Square Online to Shopify and still selling in person? We move your products, customers and order history from Square, switch in-store selling to Shopify POS with stock synced by location, and set up a 301 redirect for every old URL to protect your search rankings.

Shift Worship logo
Long Island Watch logo
Just Candy logo
Taking Cara Babies logo
Shopify Platinum Partner

16+

Years in business

500+

Projects Delivered

65+

Team Members

98%

Client Retention

1 week

Pet Planet went live on Shopify Plus in 1 week

Pet Planet went live on Shopify Plus in 1 week. Smaller catalogs like a typical Square Online store move quickly when the data is clean.

+32%

Google clicks after Camera Source's move to Shopify

Camera Source's Google clicks rose 32% in the 12 weeks after go-live compared with the 12 weeks before.

BigCommerce to Shopify

Long Island Watch moved with a full redesign

We moved Long Island Watch from BigCommerce to Shopify with a full redesign. Founder Marc Frankel talks about the project on our reviews page.

Shopify POS

Square sellers with a shop move POS too

Many Square sellers also have a physical shop. Shopify POS keeps in-store and online inventory, customers and gift cards in one admin, so we plan the POS hardware and setup alongside the online migration.

Working with Shero Commerce on our Shopify project was an absolute pleasure. Their team demonstrated exceptional expertise and professionalism. They transformed our vision into a stunning and user-friendly online store.

Reid Schwartz, eCommerce Manager, Vienna Beef

What transfers in a Square Online migration

Square Online to Shopify migration transfers products, customer records, history, blogs, and coupons, but requires a few manual steps for launch:

  • Square Online product catalog, customers, orders, and blog post transfer to Shopify
  • URL redirect map from Square Online URLs to Shopify structure
  • SEO metadata transfer: product titles, descriptions, and page metadata
  • Shopify store design replacing Square's fixed templates
  • Shopify POS setup to replace Square POS integration where applicable
  • App stack setup: reviews, email marketing, loyalty, and analytics to replace Square's included tools

Square Online to Shopify migration: your options compared

How Shero compares with staying on Square Online, Shopify's free Store Migration app, and a freelancer.

Compared on Square Online to Shopify migration agencyStay on Square OnlineShopify Store Migration appFreelancer
Products and variants Catalog checked item by item against Square after the importStay as they areFree, imports from Square's CSV exportsDepends on what the CSV exports include
Past orders Past orders imported and linked to the right customers and productsStay in SquareMoves products and customers onlyUsually a CSV or app import
Product reviews Square cannot export reviews, so we set up a Shopify reviews app before launchStay on your product pagesNot movedNot moved
Saved customer cards We plan the card transfer request with Square Support before launchStay on fileNot moved, Square sends them only on requestDepends on their checklist
How you pay Paid discovery, then an accurate estimate.Your Square Online planFree from ShopifyHourly
Square Online to Shopify migration agency
Products and variants Catalog checked item by item against Square after the import
Past orders Past orders imported and linked to the right customers and products
Product reviews Square cannot export reviews, so we set up a Shopify reviews app before launch
Saved customer cards We plan the card transfer request with Square Support before launch
How you pay Paid discovery, then an accurate estimate.

Compared with

Stay on Square Online

Products and variants Stay as they are
Past orders Stay in Square
Product reviews Stay on your product pages
Saved customer cards Stay on file
How you pay Your Square Online plan

Shopify Store Migration app

Products and variants Free, imports from Square's CSV exports
Past orders Moves products and customers only
Product reviews Not moved
Saved customer cards Not moved, Square sends them only on request
How you pay Free from Shopify

Freelancer

Products and variants Depends on what the CSV exports include
Past orders Usually a CSV or app import
Product reviews Not moved
Saved customer cards Depends on their checklist
How you pay Hourly

Why brands choose Shero for Square Online migration

Square Online migrations are fast when the data is clean and the redirect map is ready before launch. Both take some time to prepare correctly. Shero handles both before the new store goes live so the brand doesn't trade a Square limitation for a Shopify launch problem.

01

URL redirects in place before the new store goes live

Square Online and Shopify use different URL structures for products, pages, and blog posts. Without 301 redirects in place before launch, any organic rankings earned on Square URLs are lost on day one. Shero creates the redirect map, configures it in Shopify, and verifies it in Search Console so the SEO transition is clean.

02

Shopify store designed to replace Square's fixed templates

Square Online's fixed template system limits how much the storefront can reflect the brand's identity. Shopify's theme layer, including Online Store 2.0 with sections everywhere, gives full design flexibility. A Square migration is a chance to launch a storefront that actually looks like the brand. Shero scopes the Shopify theme design alongside the data migration.

03

Shopify POS replaces Square POS for merchants with physical retail

Merchants moving from Square Online to Shopify who also use Square for in-person POS have two options: keep Square for POS while Shopify handles online, or migrate both to Shopify POS for a unified inventory and sales view. Shero scopes the POS decision in discovery and configures Shopify POS where the brand wants a single system for in-person and online.

04

Shopify app stack configured to replace Square's included tools

Square Online bundles basic email marketing, loyalty, and analytics into its platform. Shopify separates these into specialist tools: Klaviyo for email, a dedicated loyalty platform, and GA4 or Lifetimely for analytics. After migration, Shero configures the Shopify app stack to cover what Square was providing.

05

Other SMB platform migrations Shero handles alongside Square Online

Square Online belongs to the SMB platform category alongside Big Cartel, Sellfy, Zen Cart, CS-Cart, X-Cart, and Shift4Shop. The migration approach is similar across all of them: clean data transfer, URL redirect map, store redesign, and app stack configuration. See how Shero handles Big Cartel to Shopify migration, Sellfy to Shopify migration, and Zen Cart to Shopify migration for related context.

06

Customer password reset prepared so buyers can log in at launch

Customer passwords cannot transfer between platforms. Shero prepares the reset email and triggers it at launch so customers can log in and access their order history immediately. For brands with large existing customer bases, the reset email timing needs care. Sent too early or too late, it creates unnecessary support volume.

Migration results

Numbers from client stores we have worked with.

View all case studies

Backup camera systems

+32%Google clicks in the 12 weeks after the move from Magento
+65%Google impressions, same 12 weeks vs the 12 before
Camera SourceShopify
Read the case study

Hair extensions

+14.3%conversion rate from two A/B tests
3 to 1platforms merged into one Shopify site
Invisible Bead ExtensionsShopify

Digital products

Ordergroovedigital memberships with free trials and plan changes, connected through custom middleware
Stripesubscriptions and saved cards moved off Stripe at go-live
Shift WorshipShopify

Our Work

View All
Backup Camera Systems

Camera Source

Camera Source, a Wisconsin-based manufacturer of backup camera systems for automotive, agricultural, and commercial use, built a loyal D2C and B2B customer base over 15+ years. Outgrowing a self-hosted Magento setup, the brand partnered with Shero to migrate to Shopify, delivering a native B2B dealer portal, a custom Vehicle Fitment Search, and a faster, more flexible storefront for retail customers and dealers alike.

Camera Source
Drums and Percussion

Memphis Drum Shop

Memphis Drum Shop sells drums, cymbals, and percussion instruments. To cut costs and modernize their platform, they moved from Magento to Shopify with Shero, with a CounterPoint ERP integration through iPaaS and 3 custom browsing features. Average session duration rose 22% after launch.

Memphis Drum Shop
Musical Instruments

F-Musiikki

F-Musiikki is one of Finland's leading music instrument retailers, serving both consumers and businesses with over 15,000 products. Looking to reduce costs and modernize their platform, the brand partnered with Shero to migrate from Magento to Shopify Plus and launch a hybrid B2C/B2B store in just two months.

F-Musiikki
Lacrosse and Hockey Gear

STX

Looking to scale alongside growing global markets and competitor consolidation, the premium American manufacturer of lacrosse, field hockey, and ice hockey equipment, partnered with Shero to migrate from Adobe Commerce (Magento) to Shopify, delivering a unified D2C and B2B experience, custom ERP integration, and a refined storefront that reflects the engineering quality of their products.

STX

Your rankings move with you

Migrations usually lose traffic in the redirects and the data. We plan both before a single product moves.

  • Redirect map

    Every old URL mapped to its new Shopify URL and tested before launch.

  • Data that matches

    Products, customers, orders and reviews moved and checked against the source.

  • Apps replaced

    Each plugin or extension matched to a Shopify app or custom code before the build starts.

  • Launch day watch

    Search Console, analytics and checkout monitored through launch week.

Moving from Square Online to Shopify? Let's talk.

Book a Discovery Call

Process

How a Square Online to Shopify migration works

Square Online shares its catalog with Square POS, so we plan the online store and your in-person selling together.

  1. 01

    Discovery

    We record discovery workshops, review your Square item library, online store pages, customer list and whether you plan to keep Square POS, then agree scope and acceptance criteria.

  2. 02

    Catalog

    Items, variations and modifiers map to Shopify products, variants and line item properties, with stock counts checked.

  3. 03

    Store setup

    The Shopify theme is set up, blog posts and pages move over, and Shopify POS or a Square connector is configured as needed.

  4. 04

    Redirects

    Each Square Online product and page URL gets a Shopify destination, tested before launch.

  5. 05

    UAT and launch

    You test the store in BugHerd and sign off. Customers get account invites, and in-store and online stock are compared after the first days of orders.

Frequently asked questions.

Can't find what you're looking for? Reach out to our team.

What our clients say.

We design experiences that make a difference. See what our clients have to say about working with us.

Swag Golf

"We partnered with Shero for the SWAG site development. The dev was highly nuanced, specialized and complex. The Shero team went above and beyond. They were collaborative, organized and professional, consistently setting expectations clearly and usually exceeding them."

Matt Kaminsky

Co-founder & Managing Director / Swag Golf

Vienna Beef

"Our experience with Shero Commerce has been exceptional. Their expertise in migrating our website to BigCommerce resulted in a seamless transition, and we’ve seen a significant improvement in our checkout process and overall user experience. Their web design skills have truly elevated our online presence, and we couldn’t be happier with the results."

Reid Schwartz

eCommerce Manager / Vienna Beef

Chromebook Parts

"The Shero team was quick to share insight on so much I didn’t know about paid ad tactics, and they were flexible when we wanted to change approaches on ad campaigns. Overall, I am really grateful for all the help they’ve been able to provide!"

Kara Stalboerger

Digital Marketing Specialist / Chromebook Parts

Camera Source

"The Shero team delivered exactly what they committed to for our Magento to Shopify migration project. They met the 3 month timeline, communicated clearly at every step, and the site has been stable since day one."

Chris Triplett

Owner / CEO - Camera Source / Camera Source

And you?

Let's build something great together.

Ready to scale your eCommerce business? Tell us about your project and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Locations
New York • London • Helsinki • Tirana